Spain's Supreme Court strikes down changes a company slipped in with its new time tracking system
Three changes struck down, €1,000 for CCOO. Spain's top court confirms a company could not use clock-in rules to stop counting the commute to the first client.

Spain’s Supreme Court has confirmed that a company that installs and maintains fire protection and security systems could not stop counting its technicians’ journey from home to the first client as working time. The company had written that change into its new time tracking policy in June 2025, together with a switch to a continuous working day and the withdrawal of meal vouchers, and all three measures have been struck down because they did not go through Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute, which governs substantial modifications of working conditions.
The ruling is STS 794/2026 of 6 October (Labour Chamber, cassation appeal 4/2026, judge rapporteur Ignacio García-Perrote). It dismisses the company’s appeal, upholds the judgment of the Audiencia Nacional (National High Court) of 6 October 2025 and declares it final. It also upholds the €1,000 in damages awarded to CCOO (Comisiones Obreras, one of Spain’s two largest trade unions alongside UGT) for infringing its trade union freedom, and reiterates its case law that time tracking cannot be used to introduce changes to working conditions.
How the company counted its technicians’ working time
The dispute concerns the service technicians, who travel from client to client. According to the findings of fact, the company counted the initial journey from home as working time: technicians clocked on when they left home and the working day ended at the last client’s premises. During that first journey the company could call the technician and change their destination.
Nor was the schedule informal. In July 2024 the company and the national works council signed a conciliation agreement setting a split working day for technical staff from Monday to Thursday, from 8:00 to 17:30 with an hour for lunch, and from 8:00 to 14:00 on Fridays. In August, the working day was continuous, from 8:00 to 14:30. That schedule was carried over into the 2025 working calendar.
The June 2025 time tracking policy
On 2 June 2025 the company launched a new time tracking system and announced it to staff by email, with two attachments: the app’s user manual and a “Time Tracking Policy”. Section 4.3 of that policy stated that, for field technicians, working time starts on arrival at the first client and ends when the job at the last one is finished. Neither the outbound journey from home nor the journey back would count.
The policy relied on Article 34.5 of the Workers’ Statute and on two Supreme Court rulings (STS 1305/2024 and STS 323/2025) which, according to the company, limit the treatment of travel as working time to exceptional cases of employees with no assigned workplace. It provided for exceptions: if the journey went outside the province or was much longer than usual, it could be counted after deducting the time equivalent to 25 kilometres, with prior authorisation on a case-by-case basis.
On 27 June another email arrived, this time announcing “an important update to the working hours policy” with three measures:
- A continuous working day from Monday to Friday, starting 14 July, with a 30-minute break counted as working time, instead of the split day with an hour for lunch.
- Withdrawal of meal vouchers, because without a long break there would be no lunch to justify them.
- The journey from home no longer counts as working time, “in accordance with the case law of the Supreme Court”.
The company added that the continuous working day “does not amount to a substantial modification”, because it had “observed” that many technicians were already working from 7:30 without stopping for lunch, and that it was simply formalising actual practice.
A change included in a time tracking policy does not count as notification
In its cassation appeal, the company argued that the claims brought by UGT and CCOO were out of time. If the change to travel time had been notified in the email of 2 June, with the policy attached, the time limit for challenging a substantial modification (20 working days) had already expired. It had not raised this at first instance, but a time bar of this kind can be raised by the court of its own motion, and the Supreme Court examined it. The Public Prosecutor’s Office backed the company on this point.
The Chamber replies that the email of 2 June announced a time tracking system, and that its case law “rules out the time tracking system being used to introduce changes to working conditions” (citing STS 565/2023, 994/2023 and 410/2024). A change in how time is counted, included in an attached document about how to clock in, is not formal notice of that change. It adds that this way of communicating is hard to reconcile with the “transparent and predictable” working conditions required by Directive (EU) 2019/1152, which Royal Decree 723/2026 of 9 September has partly transposed into Spanish law (although it did not apply to these facts because of the dates involved).
The time limit began to run on 27 June, with the first email that expressly announced the change, so the claims were filed in time. For the company, including the change in the clock-in policy had an effect it probably did not intend, since the 20-day period did not start with the 2 June email.
Even if case law were on its side, it had to negotiate
The company’s underlying argument was that the law did not require it to count that journey. For workers with no fixed workplace, the CJEU’s Tyco ruling (case C-266/14, 2015) treats the journey from home to the first client and from the last client back home as working time, and the employer argued that the Supreme Court had narrowed that doctrine. We looked at the issue in another travel-time case, the Audika manager who didn’t clock in.
The Supreme Court does not rule on that point. Nothing prevents a company from counting travel as working time even if the law does not require it, and if it has been doing so and wants to stop, it must follow Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute. Nor can it rely on the argument that there was no acquired right because it never intended to grant one. Citing STS 288/2025, the Chamber says the substantial modification procedure applies when the company had in practice been counting that time, “without even needing to determine whether or not this constituted a more beneficial condition” (the Spanish doctrine under which a benefit granted voluntarily and consistently becomes an acquired right).
The company presented the change as bringing its practice into line with case law, and in its appeal insisted that the journey was not working time under the law. For the Supreme Court, the reference point is what the company had actually been applying, even if it was more generous than the legal minimum. The approach is relevant to any company with staff on the road that changes its clock-in system, because the new system usually comes with its own way of marking the start and end of the working day. If under the old system the clock started on leaving home and under the new one it starts at the first client, that technical adjustment changes working time. Had the company opened a consultation period (the mandatory negotiation with workers’ representatives that collective changes require), the debate would have turned on whether there were grounds justifying the change (Article 41.1 of the Workers’ Statute), where it would have had a stronger case to make.
The company did not prove what it claimed to have “observed”
On the continuous working day and the vouchers, the Supreme Court takes the company’s own email at its word. If a “new” schedule is introduced, it is different from the previous one, and if vouchers are “withdrawn”, they were being provided before. It also gives weight to the fact that the split day with an hour for lunch was set out in an agreement signed with the works council, so the company was unilaterally changing something that had been agreed.
The employer said it had observed that technicians were already working a continuous day from 7:30, but it did not prove this, and the Chamber rejects the idea that it was for the workers to show they were still keeping to the 2024 schedule: “if it is the company that ‘observes’ that the schedule is in practice no longer the one set by this agreement, it is for the company to prove that observation”. The judgment does not detail what the company submitted at trial. It is striking that the new time tracking system had been running since 2 June and yet the judgment does not mention any clock-in data backing up that observation.
€1,000 for skipping the consultation period
CCOO sought €7,500 for the infringement of its trade union freedom. The Audiencia Nacional awarded €1,000, applying the criteria of the LISOS (Spain’s law on labour infringements and penalties), and the Supreme Court upholds that amount. The company argued that there was no substantial modification and that, in any case, the parties to the consultation period could have been different. The Chamber replies that the infringement is objective: by not opening consultations, the company prevented those entitled to take part from forming the negotiating committee. The company’s good-faith belief that consultations were not needed is relevant only to the amount.
The figure is low because, according to the judgment, no aggravating factors were proven and there was no evidence of the number of workers affected or the company’s turnover. Because the measures are void, the company must also restore the previous conditions: the split working day of the 2024 agreement, the meal voucher tied to it and counting the first journey as working time.
What to check before introducing or changing a time tracking system
The case is similar to one we covered in May, CIRCET at the High Court of Justice of the Canary Islands, where the company included deadlines for holidays and leave in its clock-in procedure. That TSJ ruling could still be appealed when we published it, whereas this Supreme Court ruling is final. For companies with maintenance technicians, installers or sales reps on the road, there are three things to do before making any changes to the clock-in system.
- Before switching systems, document how working time is currently counted. If the old system marked the start of the day on leaving home, the new one cannot start counting at the first client without going through Article 41.
- Separate the technical clock-in manual (how to clock in, how to correct a missed clock-in, what is recorded) from any rule about what counts as working time, schedules or benefits. Instructions on how to clock in fall within the employer’s management powers, whereas changing what counts as working time, the schedule or a benefit has to go through Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute.
- If there is a change in conditions, communicate it as such, in writing and expressly, and with a consultation period if it is collective. An annex to the clock-in manual does not count as notification, and the period for challenging the change does not start running with it.
The new Royal Decree on digital time tracking, which is still going through the approval process and has not yet been published in the BOE (Spain’s Official State Gazette), provides that companies must approve a time tracking protocol. If it is approved, the doctrine in this judgment will also apply to that protocol, which cannot change, without negotiation, what counts as working time, the schedule or benefits already in place.
How Cleverfy solves it
Cleverfy is time tracking and working-hours recording software for SMEs and the self-employed. For teams that spend the day moving between clients, it records working time according to the rules the company has set:
- Clock in from your phone at the moment the working day starts, whether at home, in the van or at the first client, with optional geolocation.
- Continuous recording across locations, for technicians who change site or client several times a day.
- Continuous or split working-day schedules, including summer hours, assigned to one person or to several at once.
- Communications with acknowledgement of receipt (Documents module, Pro plan): you publish the new schedule or the clock-in policy to the whole workforce or to a single site, and see who has consulted it and who has confirmed receiving it. Each confirmation records the date, the time and the device, and if you update the document, confirmation is requested again. It does not replace the consultation period, but it leaves a record of what was communicated, to whom and when.
- Traceable corrections: every change stores the reason, who requested it and who approved it.
- Time record reports in PDF and Excel to hand over whenever the Labour Inspectorate or workers’ representatives request them.
You can explore Cleverfy’s features, including time tracking across multiple workplaces, see the document manager with acknowledgement of receipt, try Cleverfy free for 14 days, book a demo or check our plans.
This article provides general information about a specific court decision and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, it is advisable to consult an employment lawyer.
Sources:
- STS 794/2026, dated 6 October (Supreme Court, Labour Chamber, cassation appeal 4/2026, ROJ STS 4284/2026), CENDOJ
- Workers’ Statute, Articles 34, 41 and 59.4
- Labour Jurisdiction Act (Ley reguladora de la jurisdicción social), Article 138
- Directive (EU) 2019/1152 on transparent and predictable working conditions
Frequently asked questions
Can a company change working conditions through its time tracking policy?
No. In STS 794/2026, Spain's Supreme Court repeats that the time tracking system cannot be used to introduce changes to working conditions, citing its earlier rulings 565/2023, 994/2023 and 410/2024. If a company wants to change what counts as working time, the schedule or a benefit it has been providing, it must follow Article 41 of the Workers' Statute, with a consultation period with workers' representatives when the change is collective.
Is the commute from home to the first client working time?
For employees with no fixed workplace, the CJEU (case C-266/14, Tyco, 2015) considers it working time. In this case the Supreme Court does not actually decide that question. It is enough for the court that the company was already counting it as working time. Even if the law did not require it, ceasing to do so was a substantial modification and needed the Article 41 procedure.
When does the time limit for challenging a change included in a clock-in policy start to run?
The time limit for bringing a claim against a substantial modification (20 working days, under Article 59.4 of the Workers' Statute and Article 138.1 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act, LRJS) starts with written notification of the decision. In STS 794/2026 the Supreme Court did not accept the email that introduced the new time tracking system, with the policy attached, as notification. It counted the period from a later email that expressly announced the change, which is why the claims brought by UGT and CCOO were filed in time.
You might also like

STS 372/2026, the Supreme Court sets when the worker must prove overtime
Ruling 372/2026 (15 April): the Supreme Court unifies doctrine on the overtime burden of proof when the company keeps no records.

Electrical firm to pay €8,991 for not producing time records
An electrical firm owes €8,991 in overtime after failing to produce the time records a court requested. The Basque High Court overturns its first-instance win.
Need time tracking?
Set up Cleverfy in less than 10 minutes and comply with regulations from today.
Start 14-day free trial →The information in this article is provided for informational purposes and was verified on its publication or last update date; it may have changed and may contain errors. Third-party product data comes from public sources. Cleverfy does not guarantee its accuracy and accepts no responsibility for decisions made based on it. Always check official sources before acting.