Features
Demo Pricing Compliance Check Blog Contact
← Blog | 📰 News

Electrical firm to pay €8,991 for not producing time records

An electrical firm owes €8,991 in overtime after failing to produce the time records a court requested. The Basque High Court overturns its first-instance win.

By Cleverfy ·
Electrical firm to pay €8,991 for not producing time records

A labourer at an electrical installation company lost his overtime claim at first instance, even though he had submitted his job sheets and the court had ordered the company to produce its working time records. The company handed over neither those records nor any other evidence of the worker’s working hours. The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (TSJ) has now overturned that ruling and ordered the firm to pay him €8,991, plus late-payment interest, in STSJ PV 3707/2026, of 10 November (Social Chamber, appeal 1503/2026). The judgment is not yet final and can be challenged before the Supreme Court through an appeal for the unification of doctrine.

Overtime claimed with job sheets, and time records that never arrived

The worker, on a salary of €2,463.13 a month including the pro-rated extra payments, had been with the company since May 2021 and went on sick leave on 7 March 2024. He claimed €17,918.21 for the overtime he had worked from January 2023 up to that day.

He submitted emails sent to the company and job sheets that, as his appeal describes them, set out for each day the work done, the start time, lunch, the finish time and the total hours. In his claim he also requested two pieces of evidence: his employer’s working time records for 2023 and 2024, and a paper mill’s record of the hours he and the company had worked at its site.

On 30 December 2024 the court granted both requests. Neither the company nor the paper mill produced those records.

Even so, the Court of First Instance of Donostia/San Sebastián dismissed the claim on 4 May 2026. According to its judgment, the emails did not show the hours, the job sheets did not prove that those days had actually been worked, and it had not been established what the worker’s working hours were. It also held that the claim for the hours from January to October 2023 was time-barred.

The TSJ holds the lack of evidence against the company

The Chamber applies STS 372/2026, of 15 April, which allocates the burden of proving overtime according to the type of schedule. Where there is a fixed, known schedule and no time records, the worker has to provide prima facie evidence that it was exceeded, and the burden then shifts to the company. Where there is no fixed schedule, it is the company that has to prove the hours actually worked. If it fails to do so and keeps no records either, the hours the worker claims are taken as true, provided he specified them in good time and they are not illogical.

In this case nobody had established what working hours the labourer had, and the company said nothing on the matter either. The first-instance court had held that gap in the evidence against the worker. The TSJ holds it against the company, which despite the court order failed to produce “the time record it was obliged to keep” (“el registro horario que estaba obligada a llevar”) or any other evidence such as job sheets or witnesses. It concludes that “the lack of evidence of the excess hours he claims cannot be made to fall on the worker” (“no puede hacerse recaer en el trabajador la falta de prueba de los excesos horarios que reclama”).

The judgment also quotes article 94.2 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act, which allows the other party’s allegations to be taken as proven when, without good reason, a requested document is not produced, but it bases the award on the Supreme Court’s case law. In the ABaC restaurant case the court did apply that provision. In Donostia, the lack of records had no consequences until the appeal.

The TSJ does not decide whether the job sheets were accurate, nor does it explain why the records did not turn up, and there is nothing to show that the company did not have them. It is enough for the court that the working hours are unproven and the company has provided nothing. Had the company produced reliable records, in our view the burden would have shifted to the worker, because STS 372/2026 presumes the data in those records to be true and requires anyone disputing them to prove otherwise. Nor could the retention period serve as an excuse, because when the court order arrived, the records requested were still within the four years set by article 34.9 of the Workers’ Statute.

Six months time-barred and an €8,991 award

The time bar spares the company part of the claim, though less than the first-instance court had decided. The TSJ applies its established approach, under which the one-year period starts after the payslip for the following month and the four further months in which the company can compensate the hours with time off, unless the collective agreement or the contract says otherwise. Since the conciliation request was filed in November 2024, only the hours from January to June 2023 are time-barred.

The rest is calculated from the figures in the claim, because the company offered no alternative figure:

  • €5,130.09 for 239.5 overtime hours in the second half of 2023, the result of subtracting 848 hours of standard working time from the 1,087.5 hours worked.
  • €3,860.50 for the 2024 hours.

The judgment rounds the total to €8,991, to which the late-payment interest under article 29.3 of the Workers’ Statute is added. No costs are awarded.

Awards without records, and claims stopped by them

The Basque Country TSJ has already ordered a restaurant in Bizkaia to pay €3,311.70 because it could not prove the working hours of a kitchen assistant. The Madrid TSJ upheld €41,192 against a property management firm with no clock-in system, with the employee’s own Excel sheet as the basis for the calculation.

Also in the Basque Country, a bakery produced its records and stopped a claim for 624 overtime hours, and DIA did the same with another claim for €3,938.95.

What to check if your team works on building sites or at client premises

The labourer had worked at a paper mill, but the TSJ faults his employer for not producing the records it was obliged to keep. If you have staff working away from your premises, check the following:

  • Your company keeps its own daily record of each worker’s start and finish times, including for anyone who spends the day at a client’s premises.
  • Records for the last four years are easy to locate. In this case the court order came almost ten months after the worker went on sick leave.
  • If you use job sheets, cross-check them against the time records and clear up any discrepancy with the employee before it reaches court.

If you receive a claim and have no records, provide other evidence of working hours. STS 372/2026 does not limit that evidence to time records, and the TSJ gives job sheets and witnesses as examples. We review how overtime is proven without a time record for each type of schedule.

How Cleverfy solves it

Cleverfy is time tracking and working time recording software for SMEs and self-employed professionals. For a company with staff on building sites or at client premises, it provides records of its own to produce if a court asks for them:

  • Clock in from your phone in two taps, with optional geolocation at the moment of clocking in.
  • Shared tablet with PIN for crews who prefer not to use their own phones.
  • Offline mode, which saves the actual time and syncs when the signal returns.
  • Hours by work centre, with each site kept separate.
  • Overtime tracking with alerts, to spot any excess before it builds up.
  • A history of every correction, keeping the record traceable and available whenever it is needed.

If you want to see how it works, take a look at our time tracking software for construction and building sites, try it free for 14 days or book a demo. Our plans are on the pricing page.


This article is general information about a specific court ruling, which is not yet final, and does not constitute legal advice. For specific situations, consult an employment lawyer.

Sources:

Frequently asked questions

What happens if a company does not produce the time records a Spanish court asks for?

Article 94.2 of the Labour Jurisdiction Act allows the other party's allegations to be taken as proven if, without good reason, a requested document is not produced. In STSJ PV 3707/2026 the company produced neither its records nor any other evidence of working hours, and the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country, applying STS 372/2026, ordered it to pay €8,991 in overtime. The judgment is not final.

Can job sheets be used to claim overtime?

This judgment does not settle what they are worth as evidence. The first-instance court found them insufficient and dismissed the claim against the company. The TSJ overturned that decision without assessing them. Applying STS 372/2026, it concluded that the lack of evidence could not fall on the worker, because his working hours had not been established and the company produced neither its records nor any other evidence.

How long do you have to claim overtime?

The claim becomes time-barred after one year. Under the approach taken by the Basque Country TSJ, unless the collective agreement or the contract says otherwise, the period starts after the payslip for the following month and the four further months in which the company can compensate those hours with time off. In this case, with the conciliation request filed in November 2024, only the hours from January to June 2023 were time-barred.

#overtime#time records#burden of proof#electrical installations#TSJ Basque Country#case law

Need time tracking?

Set up Cleverfy in less than 10 minutes and comply with regulations from today.

Start 14-day free trial →

The information in this article is provided for informational purposes and was verified on its publication or last update date; it may have changed and may contain errors. Third-party product data comes from public sources. Cleverfy does not guarantee its accuracy and accepts no responsibility for decisions made based on it. Always check official sources before acting.